Highlights for Models of Teaching

Direct Instruction:

Hunter Model

  • Get students set to learn

  • Create anticipatory set - gain student attention

  • State the lesson objectives

  • Present information effectively

  • Check for understanding & give   guided practice

  • Allow for independent practice

Benefits & Limits of Direct Instruction

Benefits:

  • Increases achievement scores

  • Structured for concrete sequential learners

  • Works well with lower and mid level ability learners.

Limits:

  • Tends to limit critical and creative thinking

  • Discourages self-directed learning

  • Frequently not challenging for highly able learners

Lecture

  • Teacher presents information verbally

  • Typical format is

–introduction

–body of the presentation

–closure

  • Visuals often used to illustrate points

  • Examples are often included to clarify points

Benefits and Limits of Lecture

Benefits:

  • Efficient way to cover a large volume of content

  • Relatively short period of time required to present

  • Works well with large groups of students

  • Relatively easy to prepare

  • ‘Low overhead’ – no equipment required

Limits:

  • Easy to overload learners with information

  • Slow note takers may be at a disadvantage

  • Motivation tends to be low

  • Relevance/interest may be overlooked

  • No guarantee of application of information

Expository Teaching

David Ausubel Model

  • Advance organizer to begin the lesson

  • Concepts are presented by the teacher

  • Examples & Non-examples to clarify the concept

  • Teacher refers back to advanced organizer to link the organizer with the concept in the lesson

  • This model emphasizes deductive reasoning.

Benefits & Limits of Expository Teaching

Benefits:

  • Good for presenting concepts, especially abstract

  • Focus is on comparison and contrast thinking

  • Higher level yet teacher directed

Limits:

  • Requires teacher skills for linking advanced organizer with targeted concept(s), pointing out similarities and differences

  • Some abstract concepts may be too challenging for concrete thinkers.

Cooperative Learning Principles:

Johnson & Johnson, 1994

  • Positive Interdependence

  • Face-to-face interaction

  • Individual accountability

  • Social skills

  • Group processing

This model emphasizes academic and social objectives.

Benefits & Limits of Cooperative Learning

Benefits:

  • Increases achievement scores

  • Easy to integrate multiple intelligence or learning style theory

  • Works well with any content.

Limits:

  • Requires careful monitoring

  • Takes time to plan various activities and distinct job descriptions for group members

Inquiry & Problem-Based Learning

  • Teacher presents a puzzling event

  • Learners formulate hypotheses

  • Collect and analyze data

  • Draw conclusions

  • Reflect on original problem

  • Reflect on the thinking process

Benefits & Limits of Inquiry and Problem-based Learning

Benefits:

  • Authentic tasks are highly motivating for learners

  • Application of problem solving skills

  • Uses steps of the scientific method

Limits:

  • Little or no positive affect on achievement scores – in some cases may even decrease standardized achievement scores

  • This model takes time for the process to be completed.

Concept Attainment

  • The teacher explains the rules of the game

  • Teacher gives ‘Yes’ and ‘No’ examples

  • Learners look for similarities and differences

  • Learners propose hypotheses

  • The class tests each hypotheses with more teacher supplied examples

  • The object is to discover the rule (concept)

  • When the hypothesis seems correct, students generate examples for the teacher to check

  • Teacher transitions into a lesson or an assignment

Benefits & Limits of Concept Attainment

Benefits:

  • Focus is on deep understanding of a concept

  • High learner motivation and involvement

  • Can be adapted for simple to very sophisticated concepts

  • Encourages clarification of concepts; similarities and differences between concepts

Limits:

  • May be too challenging for convergent thinkers

  • Takes more time to prepare this type of lesson – particularly identifying good examples and non-examples of the concept

Discovery Learning

  • Discovery focuses on questioning

  • Inductive reasoning

  • Intuitive thinking

  • Can be guided or unguided

  • Begin with examples

  • Teacher asks questions to lead students to discover the big idea

Benefits & Limits of Discovery Learning

Benefits:

  • Increases learner interest and motivation

  • Stimulates creative and critical thinking

Limits:

  • Little or no positive affect on achievement scores – in some cases may even decrease standardized achievement scores

  • May be too challenging for lower level & highly concrete sequential learners.

Socratic Questioning

  • Teacher does not present material

  • Teacher uses questioning techniques to lead students to analyze, critique, evaluate their own thinking and beliefs.

Types of Socratic questions:

–History of their thinking

–Implications / results

–Perspectives

–Evidence / support

Benefits and Limits of Socratic Questioning

Benefits:

  • Stimulates careful observation

  • Stimulates skill development

  • Encourages communication skills

Limits:

  •  Little or no positive affect on achievement scores – in some cases may even decrease standardized achievement scores

  • Appeals to higher level thinkers – may intimidate lower ability learners

  • Requires high level of teacher skill

Cognitive Behavior Model

  • Overt self-guidance

  • Faded self-guidance

  • Covert self-guidance

(I do it, we do it, you do it)

Benefits and Limits of Cognitive Behavior Model

Benefits:

  • Stimulates critical and reflective thinking

  • Stimulates concept development

  • Encourages independent learning

Limits:

  •  May not emphasize concepts / big picture

  • Requires accurate teacher demonstrations

 

This website brought to you by Paul Kersey & Friends

Updated 02/17/03